Geoff Pierson (48)

Jack Malloy

Stephanie Hodge (40)

Jennie Malloy

Kevin Connolly (23)

Ryan Malloy

Nikki Cox (19)

Tiffany Malloy

Justin Berfield (11)

Ross Malloy

Bobcat Goldthwait (35)

Mr. Floppy (voice)

Allan Trautman (42)

Mr. Floppy (puppeteer)

Vanessa Guild

Vanilla

Deborah Kellner (20)

Muffy

Frank Lloyd

White-Coated Man, FBI Guy #1, Security Guard, Policeman, Abominable Snowman, Teeth McKenzie

Oliver Muirhead

Mr. Monteleone

Christina Moore (24)

Cherri

Wendy Benson-Landes (26)

Barbara Caufield

Benjamin Shelfer

Beau, Johnny

Suanne Spoke

Ms. Musante, Prudish Woman

Don Novello (54)

Guy Macaroon, Father Guido Sarducci

Karen Lynn Scott

Marilyn

Bridget Flanery (27)

Bunny

J. Stewart Burns (27)

J. Stewart Burns, Singing Stuffed Animal (voice)

Dawn Fine

Secretary, Singing Ballerina Clock (voice)

Dana Daurey (21)

Amber

Ant (30)

Barry

Michael Houston King (27)

Chad

Natalia Cigliuti (19)

Francesca

Kevin Curran

Crazy Lou

Jordan Levin

Jordan Levin

Jelene Daney

Mindy

Ed O'Bannon (25)

Ed O'Bannon

Eric Tecosky

Joey

David Youse (31)

Skip