Abbi Jacobson (34)

Princess Bean (voice)

Lucy Montgomery (43)

Bunty (voice)

Nat Faxon (42)

Elfo (voice)

Tress MacNeille (67)

Queen Oona / Prince Derek (voice)

Matt Berry (44)

Prince Merkimer (voice)

David Herman (51)

The Herald (voice)

Maurice LaMarche (60)

Odval (voice)

Billy West (66)

Sorcerio (voice)

Eric André (35)

Luci (voice)

John DiMaggio (49)

King Zøg (voice)

Noel Fielding (45)

Stan the Executioner (voice)

Phil LaMarr (51)

God (voice)

Lauren Tom (57)

Trixy (voice) /

Chris Vallance

(voice)

Meredith Hagner (31)

Mora (voice) / (voice) / Mora / Mop Girl (voice)

Meloney Collins

Nun (voice)

Eduardo Roman

Radio Announcer (voice)

Meredith Pyle

Elf / Whistler (voice) / Nun (voice)

Richard Ayoade (41)

Alva Gunderson / Gordy (voice) / Alva Gunderson (voice) / (voice)

Mark Mothersbaugh (68)

(voice)

LC Powell (38)

Elf (voice)

Baraka May

Elf (voice) / Nun (voice)

Jeny Batten

(voice) / Kissy the Elf (voice) / Bathing Beauty (voice) / Kissy the Elf / Ursula (voice) / Tess (voice) / Tess / Maiden #1 (voice) / Girl in Play (voice) / Robber 1 (voice)

Rich Fulcher (49)

(voice) / Turbish (voice) / Cloyd (voice) / Cloyd / Turbish (voice) / Son in Crowd (voice) / Ole / Boy in Play #1 / Boy in Play #2 (voice) / Cloyd / Turbish / Malfus the Philosopher (voice) / Turbish / Cloyd (voice) / Satan (voice)