Michael J. Woodard (23)

Arlo (voice)

Mary Lambert (32)

Bertie (voice)

Jonathan Van Ness (34)

Furlecia (voice)

Haley Tju (20)

Alia (voice)

Brett Gelman (44)

Marcellus (voice)

Tony Hale (50)

Teeny Tiny Tony (voice)

Phil LaMarr (54)

Bruce (voice) / Sailor 3 (voice)

Ryan Crego (36)

Old Timey Singer (voice)

Michelle McMillan

Old Woman (voice) / Walla (voice) / Sailor 2 (voice) / Sailor 4 (voice) / Chicken Vendor (voice) / Leisure Wear (voice) / Ms. Jeromio Smith (voice) / Stroller Woman (voice) / Young Woman (voice) / Long Haired Woman (voice) / Random Crowd Person (voice) / Crowd (voice) / TV Reporter (voice)

Mark Whitten (34)

Deckhand (voice) / Male Cop (voice) / Baby Teeth (voice) / Rat King (voice) / Garbage Collector 1 (voice) / Walla (voice) / Sam (voice) / Tony's Dad (voice) / Family (voice) / Cats (voice) / Alro (voice) / Old Man (voice) / Townsperson (voice) / Crowd (voice) / Baby Teeth (voice) / Mr. Jeromio Jones (voice)

Fred Tatasciore (53)

Jeromio (voice) / Grant (voice) / Dust Ghost (voice) / Jeromio (voice) / Driving Guy (voice) / Detective Stroller / Unfulfilled Old Man (voice) / Chicken Customer (voice) / Beast (voice)

Cathy Vu

Thao (voice) / Clown (voice) / News Anchor (voice)

Maria Bamford (50)

Wife (voice) / Kids (voice) / Walla (voice) / Tony's Mom (voice) / Family (voice) / Cats (voice) / Cop (voice) / Bortie (voice) / Granny (voice) / Garbage Collector 2 (voice) / Aunt Guy (voice)

Melissa Villaseñor (33)

Lily the Lobster Woman (voice)

Vincent Rodriguez III

Ansel (voice) / Ansel (voice) / Child Ansel (voice)

Jessica Williams (32)

Mayor Elena (voice)

Annie Potts (68)

Edmee (voice)

Jennifer Coolidge (59)

Stucky (voice)

Flea (58)

Ruff (voice)

Santigold

Bog Lady (voice)